Talking to Professors
A page within Oral History Program
College Studentness: the living, working, social, and emotional conditions associated with being a college student at UW-La Crosse, from 1909 to the present day.
Think about the academic component of college life: coursework, homework, exams, and tutoring might come to mind? But what about the people who teach college students? When we think about what professor-student relationships look like on a college campus, this photo from the 1986 Racquet yearbook might be what we envision:
But what does it sound like when former college students remember the people who helped them learn? In this post, we’re featuring recollections from the “College Life: What We Remember” oral history project that highlight another essential component of college life: forming effective working relationships – and sometimes even longer-term connections – with instructors. In honor of the UWL FYS 100 curriculum’s Week 4 theme “Talking to Your Professors,” we’ve assembled stories about teachers who surprised students by having more complex personalities than originally assumed, whose mentorship made a difference, and who created informal after-class Q & A sessions. And, rounding out this picture with bonus primary sources that bring two professors themselves into the conversation lets us include evidence about how professors think about connecting with their students and improving students’ abilities to learn course material.
The transition from high school to college can create new sets of challenges: academic ones, social ones, and ones related to personal and professional growth. The primary source excerpts we’ve assembled highlight cases where forming working relationships with professors helped interviewees alleviate some of these college-related difficulties throughout the years. Some could still recall a favorite professor by name. Taken together, these stories in this blog post remind us how college campuses are places where people work together to help each other succeed.
Professors As Multifaceted Personalities
As college students move from large first-year courses to upper-level courses in their majors, minors, and concentrations, their impressions of the person doing the grading can change—sometimes significantly. Listening to Wayne describe a few examples of what he remembers about Geography and History faculty he took courses with in the 1970s illustrates their multifaceted personalities. This view of instructors as multidimensional characters is further evidenced by yearbook and magazine profiles of memorable faculty members. In the 1983 Racquet yearbook, we are introduced to Dr. Barnebey, an instructor who inspires students with more than just his lessons. And in the magazine for the College of Business Administration (Building Bridges) business professor Joe Chilsen discusses how he gets his students to connect with him on a personal level. Interestingly, Wayne also describes meeting one of his professors at their house for additional help on schoolwork. Ongoing research with potential future interviewees suggests that Wayne is not alone in having experienced this and that meeting with professors at their homes might have been a fairly common occurrence in the 1970s and before.
Wayne (first year: 1973)
Clip Length: 10:08
Transcript
Wayne: One of the things I remember a lot is Ed Weinzierl—who’s deceased now, but—we had him for a class called “Maps and Landforms.” And I remember it was in a lecture hall that slanted down to the floor. And Ed was working at the overhead. You remember those…machines? And we were taking some notes and he was going over different landforms and there was two couples down in the front and they were kind of talking. And he kind of looked at them, gave ‘em that stink eye, and they quieted down. Ten minutes later they started chit-chattin’ and he stopped and he just read them the riot act and threw them outta class, said “don’t ever come back.” And that made quite an impression on me. And the next year we took a course through Ed Weinzierl, it’s called “Geomorphology.” And one of the requirements was to have a weekend in the Baraboo Range. And so he drove us to Baraboo, and we studied the landforms and we got to know him very, very, well. And I remember him, the second morning we were there, we got on this landform, it was called the roche moutonnée—it’s a French term. And he had a thing of cigars in his pocket, and he whips ‘em out and he says “anybody for a cigar?” And a bunch of us went up and grabbed a cigar, and we were smoking a cigar and learning a lot about landforms. And I remember that to this day. And we really liked Ed Weinzierl, he’s a very good teacher and made a good impression upon me. Then I had a history professor, and I’m trying to think of his name, but I took a course on Latin American politics. When I was teaching high school at Brookwood High School, where I spent my career and I had to take an extra course and he had me meet him at his house. He lived between the campus and the old Kmart. And it was an election year and he wanted to watch the presidential debate. And so, I met at his house before the debate and we did… a series of readings and we discussed them and then we watched a little bit of the debate and I drove home. But not often do you go to a professor’s house for a class. And I’m trying to remember his name. I’m looking at your list here, see if I can…
Wayne: Well, I don’t see his name here. But anyway, that made quite an impression on me. I thought I was movin’ up the ladder when you got to go to the professor’s house and discuss your homework.
Gavin: So, I guess you really established some good working relationships with quite a few professors?
Wayne: I did, I enjoyed the professors. I thought they were very, very, down-to-earth and they were very good to me. And as a result, I thought I got a little bit more out of the class then you normally would have.
Gavin: And that really helped you succeed in college then?
Wayne: Yep.
Gavin: And then are there any other professors then there that you see that really made an impact on you?
Wayne: Well, I see one John Hoefer. I had John Hoefer for a geography class, and it was a course on—what was the name of the course? I think it was like a cultural geography. And we walk into—he’s kind of a little bit on the unusual side, I would say. And we walked into the class and he looked at us all and he goes “ein bisschen Land und ein bisschen Menschen.” And we looked at him like, “what?” And he said “that’s a little bit of land and a little bit of people,” and that was the basis of the course—and that was day one. About halfway through the semester, we’re in the second floor in Cowley [Hall] and someone came in and whispered in his ear and he looked a little rattled. Come to find out his house was on fire.
Gavin: Really?
Wayne: Yeah, he lived down on State Road, not too far from campus and he always rode this little scooter to school. It was like a 50 cc scooter. It was always down below, we could see it. He finished the class, went out of that building with a little double-step, went down and got on his scooter and tended to his house. He told us about it the next week. It didn’t burn down…but he didn’t leave right away, and I’ll never forget that.
Gavin: Really?
Wayne: Yeah, John Hoefer was his name. I enjoyed him. And Jerry Culver, I mentioned his wife taught anatomy classes, physiology classes, and he was the head of the Geography department for a while. And I would usually meet him down at the [La Crosse] Public Library on 7th Street. He’d be reading the newspapers and he’d be taking a lunch break, and I’d sometimes ride my bike down there and read a magazine or newspaper, or just go take a ride and he was down there practically every day, reading the newspaper at 11:30, 12:00. And I only had him for one class, but I do remember him. And I think my favorite teacher was Robert Wingate.
Gavin: Ok.
Wayne: Robert Wingate, I had a number of classes with him. He’s the one who started that Russian, Soviet Seminar class where they took a trip to Russia. And I remember, as seniors, we went on a field trip to Westby to Tri-State Breeders [Cooperative] and then down along Genoa, and he was talking about the landforms and the configurations of the area and the coulees and then we had a, we physically went in the Tri-State Breeders [Cooperative] for a maybe half-hour. And it was a very nice Saturday afternoon, I remember that. But Bob Wingate still, even after I graduated, would take tickets for football games and was he would be on staff in the stadium, keeping things in line, and even at basketball games, so I got the chance to talk to him twenty, thirty years after I graduated.
Gavin: And he was still doing that at UWL?
Wayne: Correct, correct. I still see him once in a while. Yep. Yeah, even today.
Gavin: Really?
Wayne: Yep. I mentioned this Herman Nelson. I remember him, as a freshman, sophomore, I had a couple classes with him. And he always wore bowties. He was tall, lanky gentleman and we had a class where there’s probably eighty or ninety kids in the class, it was in a lower floor of Cowley [Hall]. It might have been “Weather and Climate,” “Maps and Landforms,” one of those basic courses. And he’d take role and the next day he would call us by our name. He had this photogenic memory, where he could just [Barrett snaps his fingers] come up with the kids’ names like that. I really was kind of amazed by that. This James Parker I had for history. He was a very, very, good professor, enjoyed his work, along with Martin Zanger, those were two, maybe the most popular professors in history during the [1970]s when I was there. Everybody wanted to take their classes.
Gavin: Really?
Wayne: Yeah.
Gavin: So, it was always I guess sort of a race when you had to sign up for them?
Wayne: Correct, correct. Margaret Chew, I only had one class with Margaret Chew, she was quite elderly at the time. She ran our Geography Club for a couple years.
Gavin: Ok.
Wayne: She was kind of the lady who put that together from what I understand. And she’s had quite a interesting life, if you ever read her bio, she’s talked with kings and queens, and ridden camels in the desert with higher-ups, and she’s been all over the world. I don’t think she was ever married, from what I understand, but she had quite a life. But she was quite elderly, even when I was there, I think, but interesting lady, very interesting lady.
Gavin: Now you’d mentioned in our pre-interview meeting about a memory with John Snyder.
Wayne: Yeah, Snyder I remember, he would come into history class and he would have these big boots on with blue jeans rolled way up and he’d have a flannel shirt on. And very, very, just gonna dress the way he wanted, not the way maybe the university people wanted him to dress. And I remember one time, I believe it was him, he came and he had two pistols on his side. They weren’t loaded—you wouldn’t get away with that today—but we were studying the American West and he wanted to show us what a revolver, a Colt really looked like and how it was used by the early settlers and some of the gunslingers. And I remember that quite a bit. It made an impression upon me.
Gavin: I’d imagine.
Additional Primary Sources
How Professors Made A Difference
Looking back on working relationships with their instructors, interviewees explained how they came to see them as people who made them think differently about the purpose of college (Ashlyn), mentored their budding career interests (Alex), helped them think much more deeply about course content and projects (Aliyah), and kept them going by not giving up on them (Harry).
Ashlyn (first year: 2018)
Clip Length: 1:36
Transcript
Ashlyn: Yeah. So, you know, specifically like my Freshman year it was challenging. It's- it's challenging for most students just adjusting to that college life. So, you know, in combination with it being Freshman year and just kind of five years ago already, there's not a ton that I remember class-wise and professor-wise. I remember, you know, struggling a little bit at the start especially in math again, but once I got, you know, to into my core kind of psych classes, my Junior and Senior year, I was really able to form connections with professors, because, you know, you're taking multiple classes with certain professors. But my ceramics professor in particular, Jared Pfeiffer, he, I- I'd say it made the biggest impact on my college career, and I took multiple classes with him outside of ceramics. And I think he just really, you know, proved that well and like, yes, it's harder to have a giant art class, it's not really possible. But he just really, you know, enforced the importance to me, you know, really having a close connection with your professor. You know, more of that like one on one interaction, and I think that really- really made college- college worth it for me, and- and having at least one professor that I was able to make a connection with, it was really exciting.
Alex (first year: 2011)
Clip Length: 1:48
Transcript
Alex: Yes, and there are a couple. I want to start up with Jo Arney, who is in my thoughts because I know that she has since passed, and that's hard because she was very instrumental in me being interested in this field. She was my local government—local and state government professor—and that's where I started this journey, I, you know, interned for somebody who I would succeed. I interned for them in college and Jo was my adviser. Dianne Hesselbein was the Representative who held this seat before me. And, so Jo was my adviser when I went and interned for Diane, and then I came back to campus and later on she was my state and local government professor, and years back I look on some of the lessons that she taught and some of the practicalities of what local government is and I used that when I ran for Dane County Board and to which I still serve. And then I ran for State Representative after that, and I think of her and the things that she said and taught and that the lasting impact that she left. Then there are other faculty members, Alan Bigel was always a joy to attend his class. He had a unique way of instructing, which I definitely learned a lot from my time with him. He was a very encouraging faculty member, and really helped develop my writing skills, which I use every day now to write about law. And not having a law degree, that's very helpful for me [laughs] to know. So those are two that stick out in my mind.
Aliyah (first year: 2016)
Clip Length: 1:39
Transcript
Aliyah: Yeah, I would say my Event Management course that I or yeah, the Event Management course, we were planning that Wheels For All tournament. That professor really had an impact on me. I'm not sure if I'm allowed to say names or not. Oh, I can.
Tiffany: Yes.
Aliyah: Okay, that professor was Dr. Narcatta-Welp, I think she still teaches there. She was one of my favorites, and I still keep in touch with her, you know, on- on Facebook, so that's kind of cool to see what she's up to. But she was one of the professors, I think, that I enjoyed the most there just because she was so personable, and really made sure that you, you know, were learning the content, but also understanding it. But not- didn't just kind of leave you on your own. So I think she was probably one of the most impactful professors that I have throughout college. Going into grad school, I think it was different just because everybody had kind of come from wherever they had come from. And so it was definitely different getting to know those professors. But I did have some that I- I felt like were very helpful, and, you know, they didn't make it feel like school, which was nice. But I would say in undergrad, I think, at La Crosse, just with that smaller class sizes. I mean, not that my classes were very huge in Minnesota, but they were a little bit bigger, I would say, and just the school in general was bigger, so those professors have more classes. but the professors at UW-La Crosse, I think, and Narcatta-Welp, She was probably one of the best that I have ever had. And I think just, you know, being able to, you know, talk with her even outside her office hours, you know, just coming by to say hi, or like get some feedback on a paper. I think she was probably one of the professors I'll remember the most.
Harry (first year: 1985)
Clip Length: 1:07
Transcript
Harry: …God I wish I could think of her name, she was a phenomenal teacher. I had a biology teacher for biology, I don’t know if it’s called 101, whatever the intro to biology was, that class I loved. And the thing is I loved all my classes and I don’t say that to be sound sappy cause I do love going to school. I loved the subject. I love learning, it’s frustrating as hell cause I can’t learn like everybody else does. But I had a biology teacher who was, God what was her name, she was super popular too. But with her help, I squeaked out of that class with a C minus or a D plus. But that was a really positive experience though because she didn’t give up on me. And she constantly helped, and you could go to her for everything. I think we’re going to name a building after her I thought, and they didn’t. She used to sit right at the front of the row for Caper games, the basketball, that was the amateur basketball back then. I don’t know what they call it now or if they’re even here. But she would sit in the front row. That’s what I remember about her. But I can’t think of her name.
Talking To Professors Before The “Email Me!” Era
In the 2020s, professors and students frequently use email to communicate with each other. Students are also often urged to make the trek to instructors’ offices for the academic ritual of office hours. But Michelle, who attended UWL briefly in 1982 and then again from 1990 - 1993, describes an alternate form of communication that sometimes kind of organically emerged at the end of class meetings: professors creating an informal Q & A session by talking with students waiting after class to speak with them. The ability to send instructors an email at a later point in the day seems like it has changed the phenomenon Michelle described somewhat.
Michelle (first year: 1990)
Clip Length: 1:33
Transcript
Michelle: I absolutely felt more connected to them because for whatever reason the class sizes were smaller, probably because we were in our major. And they were just very, I mean, if you went up and asked a professor a question after class, they would talk forever, help you with whatever. I don’t remember going to their office hours per say. I don’t even know if that was a thing, but they were always available. I mean, if you asked them a question and they didn’t know the answer they would, you know, set up a time to meet with you or visit. I mean, hey I don’t know, they were always available. And in fact I wasn’t the only person that would ask questions after class. So they just- you just kind of waited your turn and they stayed long. I don’t ever remember any of them ever saying, “I have to go.”
Kevin: Okay, so what you’re saying is like once you got into like the classes for your major, your professors seemed a lot more open to you?
Michelle: Oh yeah, definitely. Cause they’re all education majors, you know. Or at one point and they all, you know, knew your questions were legit and yeah definitely. Definitely more more inviting, more. Class sizes were smaller, helpful. You know, they were very passionate about what they were doing. [Chuckles]
Can You Relate?
Building a working relationship with instructors can help students face the challenges that come with being in college. In this blog post, interviewees described seeing their professors in a new light and the importance of forming working relationships with them in college. We also provided an example that suggests a potential change from informally meeting with professors to more formal communications like email. After exploring the perspectives of professors and alumni:
What has your experience building effective working relationships with the people grading you been like?
How Alumni Can Help:
OHP definitely views our work as a collaborative effort. There are two distinct ways former college students at UWL can help the “College Life: What We Remember” project.
- Share what you remember by participating in an oral history interview. History continuously evolves as more information is brought to light. Our “College Life: What We Remember” oral history project is in its early stages: right now we only have 15 interviews. In Fall 2024 and Spring 2025 we’ll be conducting another round of interviews. Do you have memories about your college years at UWL you’d be willing to share with our project? We’re hoping to learn more about multiple aspects of college life. But as you can see from this blog post, we’re especially hoping to learn about more about which professors, advisors, tutors, and support staff made an impression on you during your college years. If you’re interested in participating in an oral history interview, please fill out this online survey to let us know. You can also contact us at oralhistory@uwlax.edu to find out more about the “College Life” oral history project.
- Make a financial donation to sustain our project. OHP relies on donations to fund our student internships and keep our oral history work going. You can make a gift online through this link: Donate to OHP.
Production credits: writing by Tiffany Trimmer, Shaylin Crack and Gavin Stebbins, research and conceptualization by Shaylin Crack, web design by Olivia Steil, collection processing by Shaylin Crack, Julia Milne, Isaac Wegner, and Gavin Stebbins.